More stories

  • in

    Tony Kushner: Larry Kramer Spoke the Truths We Needed to Hear

    For many years Larry Kramer and I were good friends.And then we weren’t — that was Larry’s decision. It was also Larry’s decision that the time had come to reconcile, a few years after a rift that was and remains heartbreaking for me. I hadn’t spoken to Larry in five years; I was standing in the Greenwich Village bookstore Three Lives, reading something, when I heard a soft, sad whispered “Anthony,” and I turned to see him, looking older and frailer than he had the last time we were together, staring up at me through thick lenses.He said, “I miss you.” I said, “I miss you too, Larry.”I really had missed him, a lot. Larry was great fun to be with, to dish dirt with over the phone or at lunch. When he was in a good mood, as he often was, he was just a grand old New York queen. He seemed to have known practically everyone, and knew or claimed to know many of their spiciest, darkest secrets.Larry also knew what made the wheels of the worlds of art and politics turn, who had called whom to make stuff happen. And he knew who failed to make the wheels turn, who failed tests of chutzpah or moral courage, by which Larry meant voluble outrage. He adored the just and brave and talented, and he adored denouncing those who had failed to act, those who had let us down.By “us,” Larry meant the L.G.B.T. community. He was an unapologetic tribalist. I often told him that I felt this amounted to a willed limitation of empathy, fatal to the necessity of building solidarity with other communities fighting for justice, enfranchisement, emancipation. He told me that I was too easily distracted and insufficiently loyal to “our people.”As Shaw, Brecht and others have observed, saints are, for the most part, unbearable company, exhausting, unnerving scourges. Larry wasn’t a saint, and he would have killed anyone who called him one. But I suspect that many official saints were as thorny as he was. His focus was so exclusive that it could sometimes feel exclusionary, but the specificity of his vision gave it an astonishing, unsettling, disruptive force. Through his singular devotion to L.G.B.T. liberation, he attained the expression of something like a visionary politics of universal value.With the force of prophetic revelation, the AIDS epidemic laid bare for Larry a terrible, galvanizing truth: Liberation from oppression is, in the most concrete sense, a matter of life and death. Therefore, oppression is as impermissible and intolerable as murder. Oppression is, in fact, murder. To him, any attempt to dodge this truth, or to hide from its imperative for immediate action, was incomprehensible and unforgivable. Comfort with oppression wasn’t bad because it might lead to a holocaust; oppression was the holocaust, and comfort was complicity.Larry had much in common with Susan Sontag, who, in “Illness as Metaphor” and later in “AIDS and Its Metaphors,” admonished us to strip disease of all meaning beyond its biology. To assign moral or literary rather than scientific meaning to illness, she argued, is to use the suffering of others, often for the purpose of stigmatizing them, making it easier to withhold aid, to selectively withdraw decency and humanity.Sontag’s essays helped lay the groundwork for a new rights-based politics of health care in which Larry played a vital role. They admired each other, despite reservations. They shared a furious insistence on seeing, clearly and courageously, and then on speaking out, telling others what they’d seen. Both used language as a means of pushing consciousness past every trick of language that disguises reality.I wasn’t fully out of the closet in 1983 when I read the New York Native essay “1,112 and Counting,” Larry’s primal scream/howitzer blast of a wake-up call to gay men who were struggling with the unassimilable scientific reality of a new, fatal, sexually transmitted disease. I hated the essay and I hated him for writing it; it felt abusive and violent. I wasn’t alone in feeling this. Many of us couldn’t absorb what Larry was telling us; we relegated him to the cave of our demons, the bullies and abusers with which we’d all had to contend.But for some of us — certainly for me — Larry’s scorched-earth harangue provoked painful introspection. It’s unpleasant and scary to be yelled at, but you ignore the meaning of what’s being yelled at your own peril. Larry was howling demands at us, but the shattering words of his essay articulated a stark truth. He was demanding not that we submit but that we rise up and begin to take ourselves, our lives, our health and each other as seriously as he did.And then came “The Normal Heart,” an excoriation of a play, unlike anything we’d seen before. A theatrical polemic that described the present moment with harrowing exactitude; an incredibly crafted, gorgeous, funny, devastating masterpiece of theatrical realism; and also — and this is very rare — a work of art that provably moved its audiences to political action. It’s a play about an insufferable person rising to a historical moment; it shows us horrible suffering in order to goad us to become insufferable ourselves, in the name of refusing suffering.My deep indebtedness to Larry as a writer was the basis of our friendship. I was indebted to him as a gay man and as a citizen. As a person who tries to stay politically engaged, I was in awe of him. But I loved his words, and he loved that. Larry was an artist. Sometimes he’d say that nothing mattered more to him than being respected as an artist. I believe that he was an extraordinary writer, and I also believe that he sacrificed for the sake of his unceasing activism some of what he might have accomplished artistically.I think he knew that, though he never complained about it — and Larry liked to complain. He wrote “Faggots,” “1,112 and Counting,” “The Normal Heart” and its sequel, “The Destiny of Me.” In terms of political engagement, few serious American artists have achieved more.Larry was sometimes joyful but rarely happy, at least not so he’d let anyone know about it. He was constitutionally incapable of satisfaction; for him, satisfaction = death. He wanted to be included, he wanted his community to be let in on the franchise, to have a place amid structures that permit order, stability and prosperity. He was willing to raze those structures if we were denied access, but the access, not the razing, was the point.He was relentless but not revolutionary. And yet, announcing failure and defeat and impending apocalypse, he fed a rage that formed the words that helped fuel a revolution. He was sometimes a misery and often an unmatchable mensch. He was a blisteringly magnificent solar flare of a human being. And I’ll miss him forever.Tony Kushner is a playwright and screenwriter.The Times is committed to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. We’d like to hear what you think about this or any of our articles. Here are some tips. And here’s our email: letters@nytimes.com.Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Twitter (@NYTopinion) and Instagram. More

  • in

    Review: ‘Central Park’ Is the Show We Need Right Now

    New York City needs its parks in any summer, but never more than now. Shared spaces of play, sun, respite and peace (and yes, conflict and judgment) are reminders in a time of distancing that we are all in this together.Likewise, “Central Park” is the show we need right now, even if its makers couldn’t have anticipated how and why. It arrives Friday on Apple TV Plus, and it’s as well-timed as the Mister Softee truck on a 95-degree scorcher.This weird, warm, joyful animated sitcom about a park manager and his family, living in Manhattan’s teeming, landscaped backyard, would be a cool treat at any time. In pandemic season, it’s more: a fun, full-throated tribute to public space and the people (and dogs and rats) who share it.“Central Park” is created by Loren Bouchard and Nora Smith of “Bob’s Burgers,” along with Josh Gad, and it shares several elements with that stalwart Fox sitcom — above all, a fondness for eccentric obsessives with small-scale big dreams.Owen Tillerman (Leslie Odom Jr.) loves the park the way his forebear Bob loves hamburgers, with a consuming, dorky-dad passion not always shared by the tulip-trampling masses. Central Park is his life — he even lives there, in a ramshackle “castle” that may have once been a storage shed, with his wife, Paige (Kathryn Hahn), a reporter with “the No. 1 most-left-on-the-subway paper in the city,” and his kids, Molly (Kristen Bell) and Cole (Tituss Burgess).It’s a theoretically idyllic life, made a little less so by the everyday stresses of work and budgets, and the fellow citizens who use the park as a gym, a dance floor and occasionally a restroom. The whole urban sweep, majestic greenery and grand architecture seen from above, jeers and hot-dog water up close, is laid out in the opening song, which —Oh, did I mention that “Central Park” is a full-on musical, and a legitimately good one? Where “Bob’s” sprinkles its episodes with brief, gamely sung ditties, “Central Park” features several numbers per half-hour, most of them from the staff composers, Kate Anderson, Elyssa Samsel and Brent Knopf. (Other songwriters include Sara Bareilles, of “Waitress,” who contributes a showstopper to the second episode.)Beyond the cast’s musical pedigree — including Odom and Daveed Diggs of “Hamilton,” as well as Bell and her “Frozen” co-star Gad, who plays an overeager busker-narrator — the clever, replay-worthy songs drive the narrative. The centerpiece of the pilot, “Own It,” gives each Tillerman a personal nerd anthem while also introducing the series’ villain, Bitsy Brandenham (Stanley Tucci), a hotel magnate who wants to privatize the park.Fans of “Bob’s” will notice some DNA in common, from its love of a good scatological joke to the character types. There is a bit of Tina Belcher in Molly, who draws superhero comics starring herself (her imagined superpower, being able to rewind time, represents the universal teen wish to do-over awkward moments) and moons over a secret crush. There is a good deal of Gene Belcher in Cole, who develops his own crush on Bitsy’s pampered dog.But “Central Park” has a scope and scale of its own. Visually, it’s a polished uptown cousin to the down-the-shore “Bob’s.” Narratively, it builds a serial plot around Bitsy’s supervillain scheme, along with episodic stories like one about Owen’s fear of public speaking. (“Guess it’s something I could work on/Like that guy helped Colin Firth on.”)Setting up the long game slows down the first episode, but the series builds in the four episodes screened for critics, powered by goofy, good-hearted humor. It has ideas and ideals, but it wears them lightly and keeps the messages to a minimum. The Tillermans, for instance, are a biracial family, but at least early on this goes unmentioned, unlike in recent comedies like “mixed-ish” and “Florida Girls.” (The voice casting is cross-racial and cross-gender, with Bell playing the biracial Molly and Diggs playing Bitsy’s put-upon henchwoman, Helen.)Mostly the promise of “Central Park” is in its celebration of the public commons and civic services. (In the fourth episode, Owen duets with a waste-transfer-station manager about their respective duties.) This is one more TV show that has new resonance in the pandemic era, but for once that relevance is delightful, not depressing.“Central Park” makes its setting a stand-in for urban life — all the jostling out-and-aboutness that stay-at-home orders have temporarily suppressed — its chaos and its messy democracy. You can, like Owen, beautify it and heroically clean up the trash. But you can never totally control it, because then it would stop being what it is.You can’t tame the city. We can only own it, together. More

  • in

    Leslie Odom Jr. Raises a Glass to Billie Holiday and New York City

    Leslie Odom Jr. met Josh Gad when they were drama students at Carnegie Mellon. And when Gad calls, usually about some weirdly wonderful little project, Odom tends to pick up the phone. “I always know that it’s going to be a delightful experience,” Odom said, “because it’s no secret: Josh is a delightful dude.”The admiration is apparently mutual. In “Central Park,” a new animated musical series on Apple TV Plus, Odom is the voice of Owen Tillerman, the park’s devoted manager, battling forces intent on destroying his beloved oasis. It’s a role that Gad, one of the show’s creators and stars, wrote with Odom in mind.“Central Park” also shows a softer side of Odom, most famous for his Tony-winning portrayal of Aaron Burr in the Broadway juggernaut “Hamilton.” (Disney Plus will stream a movie version beginning July 3.)Late last year, Odom released “Mr,” his first album of original material, and in early March set out on his Stronger Magic Tour. But the pandemic soon forced him back to Los Angeles, where he lives with his wife, the actress Nicolette Robinson (“Waitress”), and their 3-year-old daughter, Lucille. On a phone call, Odom elaborated on the 10 quarantine essentials that have kept him going. These are edited excerpts from our conversation.1. Billie Holiday at Carnegie HallI haven’t been home for this long a stretch since my kid has been born. I’ve never had the pleasure of putting my daughter to bed every single night. Bath time is part of the wind down for bedtime for her, and I’ve taken that as a time to help lay a really good musical foundation. One of my dad’s favorite games was that he would have his music on, and he would quiz me: Who’s this? Who’s that? And it gave me great pleasure to get the answer right. Lucille can recognize Billie’s voice now. When I ask her, “Who’s that?,” she says, “Billie Holiday.”2. “The Sopranos”I’m in the prequel David Chase wrote that deals with a pivotal summer in young Tony’s life. That audition came up fast, so I watched a couple of episodes just to learn what I could. Then I thought I would watch all six seasons. Chase writes about family and brutality and violence and criminality, but I’ve never seen it handled with quite the same economy or eloquence. There’s so much poetry in the series, all the dream stuff, plus the whole notion that a guy like Tony is putting himself on the proverbial couch. Watching someone do the hard work on themselves leads to powerful change, because it inspires someone else to do the same thing.3. Toni Morrison’s “Beloved”After I saw “The Pieces I Am,” the Toni Morrison documentary, I was like, it would be worth my time to complete my education. I’d read “The Bluest Eye,” “Song of Solomon” and maybe one other book. So at the top of quarantine, I picked “Beloved.” Sometimes it’s hard to carve out the time to sit and peacefully read with a toddler, so books on tape have been great — that one in particular, because Ms. Morrison reads it herself. I’ve had a very fun time toggling back and forth between the book and the audiobook, to have her tell the story to me. I think I know something; I know what it meant to me. And then I’ll hear her read the same phrase and it opens it up in a whole different way.4. HypeMiCWe are recording “Central Park” in quarantine. They sent us any equipment that we didn’t have so that we could keep the work going. So I’ve been recording from home. Between that and the concerts, the benefits and the fund-raisers that we’re doing online, the HypeMiC has become my favorite little mic. It sounds great.5. Words With FriendsWith all the free time, it’s been a great source of time suckage, but also of strategy and staying nimble and keeping the brain moving a little bit. I’m very, very focused right now on the six-letter word. That’s all I care about.6. Orange ChickenI like to eat good food, which means in quarantine you have got to cook good food. My in-laws, who live about five blocks away, have an orange tree, and I found a great recipe where you essentially just make a reduction from the oranges. Orange, ginger, soy sauce are the main ingredients, chicken and rice or noodles. I’ve been able to do a vegetable lo mein, a fried rice with it, and I get my Asian food fix. So orange chicken is my go-to meal, and it’s a big hit over here with the ladies.7. “Middleditch & Schwartz”I have heard about the legendary live improv show that Tom and Ben perform for years. It has always sold out too fast for me to witness in person. Enter Netflix, doing essential work in these dark times, by giving us all the literal best seat in the house — it’s the sofa for us in L.A. — for three of these longform improvised shows. Biggest laughs we’ve had in quarantine.8. Bong Joon Ho’s “Parasite” and Trey Edward Shults’s “Waves”They’re obviously both tremendous achievements in filmmaking. They both deal with class. They’re both about the messiness and the strength of family. And both of the movies packed a genuine surprise for me. I’m not unlike my kid in that way. She loves an adventure, or even a story about an adventure. And she wants to be dropped off in an entirely different place than we picked her up. Both those movies managed to be that.9. ManhattansNic has gotten so great at making this one very specific cocktail, so we treat ourselves a couple of times a week. The other thing is, we only ever lived in Manhattan when we were on the East Coast, within walking distance to the theaters. The city is on our mind all the time. So it’s also been a part of a rumination or a little prayer in some way, raising a glass to one of our favorite places on the planet, pouring one out for our city.10. Cori Doerrfeld’s “The Rabbit Listened”Putting Lucille down each night before we say our prayers — that’s a holy time. We take it very seriously as a spiritual practice for our family. And “The Rabbit Listened” is a book that she requests quite often, or that Nicolette requests because she likes it so much. It’s a sweet little book about when something sad happens, how Taylor, the little boy at the center, doesn’t really know where to turn. These animals show up and they each have a different suggestion about what he should do — whether it’s scream, cry, get even. And the rabbit is the only one of his friends that shows up to listen, so Taylor is able to tell him how he feels. I love the lesson of it. More

  • in

    How Do I Get HBO Max if I Already Have HBO?

    AT&T’s new streaming platform HBO Max went live on Wednesday, but for many HBO subscribers, it was not entirely clear whether they had access to the service.Millions currently do not. That’s because AT&T could not strike deals in time for the launch with some key distributors and a few device makers. Only those who purchased HBO through the right distributor and have the approved device could watch HBO Max.HBO Max costs the same as HBO ($15 a month) and is intended to convert HBO users to the new service, which offers twice as much content.Confused? Here’s a handy guide:For those who already pay for HBO through a traditional TV provider, you’re in luck. HBO Max hashed out agreements with most of the major players, including Comcast, the nation’s largest cable operator, thanks to a last-minute deal signed Wednesday. Those customers can download the app and sign in with their HBO Go or pay-TV account. (Here’s the full list of providers.)But if you’re planning to watch on an Amazon Fire or Roku device, you’re out of luck. AT&T could not reach agreements with either. Both Amazon and Roku get a cut of revenue from streaming providers, and the structure of those deals can get complicated. Still, there are still plenty of places to download the app. Approved devices include Apple, Samsung TVs from 2016 and later, Xbox and Chromecast. Here’s the full list.For those who bought their HBO service through a digital provider like Apple, Google Play, Hulu Live or YouTubeTV, you’re good to go. Log in to the HBO Max website or app with your HBO credentials. But the same device caveat as above applies.For those who have HBO Now, you likely bought it directly from the HBO website. You should be all set. Just log in to the HBO Max website or app with the same account.Anyone who bought HBO through Amazon Channels or a Roku device are shut out of HBO Max. Amazon and Roku provide both media access and sell devices, so they have two key areas over which to negotiate.For consumers stuck in the middle, you can cancel your HBO account to sign up on the HBO Max website and watch through an approved device. More